
There's a coffee shop in Jacksonville that's working to be anything but ordinary. The pink-walled shop is filled with the smell of espresso. The sound of people laughing fills the air. Nearby, a virtual meeting unfolds between sips of coffee, while a family settles in with pastries spread across the table.
A few years earlier, that idea for Tetherball Coffee Shop in Mandarin had only existed in Elias Jeppesen's spreadsheet.
Following His Dream
Elias spent his days working at coffee shops, restaurants and an entry-level job to chip away at debt. At night, he traded TV time for business books, scrolled through café owner Facebook groups and filled spreadsheets with ideas for a coffee shop that reflected the Florida he knew and loved.
"I didn't see any coffee shops in our city that were very representative of the culture I grew up in, which was sunny, colorful and eclectic," said Elias. "I felt there was room for a community space where I could also apply some of the skills I'd learned."
In 2021, as plans started to take shape, Elias took an important step of opening a VyStar business account.
"I wanted to start a small, local business with a community-minded institution," Elias said. " It was clear to me that VyStar was making an effort in our city and operated more like a place where I could ask questions and get genuine help."
Fourteen months later, customers pushed open the doors to a coffee shop splashed with bold colors and buzzing with energy. The menu, however, was modest.
"At that time, we only accommodated a small portion of the community, like businesspeople grabbing an espresso," said Elias. "We started realizing we needed to better serve families."
Growing a Business
Over the years, new favorites found their way onto the menu. Kids reached for a Jags Juicebox while adults paired their drinks with a Caramel Chop cookie. The shop itself evolved too. A colorful mural stretched across the wall. Custom-built benches created gathering spaces. Every addition reflected ideas shared by staff and customers.
"I like hearing what staff or customers are interested in next, whether that's a menu item or an event, and then seeing how we can make it happen," Elias said.
As the menu and experience expanded, so did the business. Strangers became regulars. First dates turned into familiar faces. Families returned week after week. Over time, he realized his work was about more than coffee. It was about creating connections, fostering community and positively affecting people's lives.
"It was clear we were acting as a space where people could bring friends and family without being asked for something in return," he said.
Soon, the calendar filled with free events. The scent of fresh pie drifted through community bake nights. Moviegoers gathered under the glow of a projector screen. On Sunday mornings, runners laced up their shoes and met at the shop before heading out together.
"I feel like being our authentic selves really encourages a lot of fun, interesting people to hang around," Elias said.
Expanding with VyStar
As the business grew, VyStar supported its expansion with solutions such as auto loans that helped the shop begin making deliveries.
"I know I can come into VyStar and get all my business done or ask questions," Elias said.
The spreadsheet that once held a collection of ideas has now been replaced by something far more tangible: a vibrant gathering place filled with the sounds, smells and connections Elias envisioned from the very beginning.